Neutral vs. Non-Neutral Smart Switches: Understanding and Choosing - MOES

Neutral vs. Non-Neutral Smart Switches: Understanding and Choosing

If homeowners wish to upgrade their house to a smart home, it is essential to understand how to connect smart switches that do not have a neutral wire. Most smart light switches require a neutral wire to function correctly.

Thus, understanding the differences between neutral and non-neutral wire switches and whether installing a neutral wire is necessary is crucial.

Additionally, some non-neutral wire switches may experience flickering issues. To help you address these concerns, we will provide a detailed analysis of these topics, starting with the basic knowledge.

Basic Principles of Light Switches

The basic working principle of a light switch is similar to that of a battery circuit. The positive terminal of the battery connects to the positive terminal of the light bulb via a wire, while the negative terminal connects to the bulb's negative terminal, forming a complete circuit.

When the switch is in the "on" position, the internal contacts close, allowing current to flow through the switch and the light fixture, thus illuminating the bulb.

At this point, the circuit forms a closed loop, with current flowing from the power source through the bulb and back to the power source.

When the switch is in the "off" position, the internal contacts open, preventing current from flowing through the switch. The circuit is interrupted, and current cannot reach the bulb, causing it to turn off.

In this state, the circuit is open at the switch, preventing the current from forming a closed loop, and the bulb remains off.

Basic Principles of Light Switches

The Concepts of Neutral and Non-Neutral Wires

In a home electrical system, power comes from a distribution board (DB), not a battery. The household wiring includes live (hot) and neutral wires, where the live wire functions similarly to the positive terminal and the neutral wire to the negative terminal.

Although the technical details differ, the "closed-loop" principle of the circuit remains applicable. Whether using traditional or smart switches, breaking the circuit will cut off power to all connected devices.

The Concepts of Neutral and Non-Neutral Wires

Traditional manual switches operate through physical toggling, while smart switches rely on relays and wireless communication, which require a continuous power supply.

If the circuit is completely cut off, smart switches cannot operate the relay or receive wireless commands. Thus, installing smart switches without a neutral wire becomes a critical issue. But what exactly is a neutral wire?

What is a Neutral Wire?

A neutral wire is a conductor that carries current back to the power source, completing the electrical circuit. In a home electrical system, the neutral wire works alongside the live (hot) wire, facilitating the flow of electricity.

The live wire brings power from the distribution board to the switch and the device (e.g., a light bulb), while the neutral wire returns the current to the board, ensuring a continuous loop for current flow.

Smart switches, which need a small but constant power supply to function their internal electronics and communication modules, often require this neutral wire to maintain the necessary power even when the load (e.g., a light) is off.

In the context of the U.S., the home electrical system steps down high voltage (13.2 kV) to 240 volts using a transformer.

The voltage difference between terminal A (+120V) and terminal B (-120V) is 240V, with the neutral wire providing a 0V reference point.

This setup is safer and more efficient, as the neutral wire offers a stable reference voltage compared to using only terminal A or B.

How to Determine if You Have a Neutral Wire

Identifying the presence of a neutral wire is crucial for installing smart switches.

Here are several methods to verify its presence:

  • Inspect the Distribution Board: Open the distribution board and look for blue wires, as neutral wires are typically blue.
  • Examine Switches or Outlets: With the power turned off, remove the faceplate of a switch or outlet to check for blue wires.
  • Measure Voltage: Use a digital multimeter to measure the voltage between the live (hot) wire and the neutral wire (should read 230V or 120V, depending on your system), and between the neutral wire and the ground wire (should be close to 0V).
  • Test the Wires: Use a voltage tester to check if the wire is live. If the tester illuminates, the wire is carrying current.
  • Consult an Electrician: If you are uncertain or encounter difficulties, it is advisable to seek assistance from a professional electrician.

Additional Notes:

  • If you find two white wires connected with a wire nut (not connected to the switch), this indicates the presence of a neutral wire, allowing for the installation of most common smart switches.
  • If you only observe three wires—two carrying current to the light (typically black and white) and one for grounding (green or bare)—then a neutral wire is not present.
not connected to the switch
typically black and white

Solutions for Smart Switches Without a Neutral Wire

In environments lacking a neutral wire, MOES offers a solution with its non-neutral smart light switches. These switches are ingeniously designed to operate without a neutral wire.

The MOES non-neutral smart light switch works by regulating the amount of power delivered to the light to control its operation.

In the "off" position, the switch transmits a very small amount of power (e.g., 1W), sufficient to power the smart switch itself but not enough to illuminate the light bulb.

This design ensures that the smart switch maintains a minimal power supply even when the circuit is off, thus ensuring the proper functioning of its features and wireless communication.

 

How to install a Non Neutral Smart Light Switch

Installing the no neutral smart light switch is a relatively straightforward process. Ensure that you have the necessary tools, including a screwdriver, wire stripper, and needle-nose pliers.

Follow these basic steps:

  • Turn Off the Power: Switch off the power at the main circuit breaker to ensure safety.
  • Remove the Old Switch: Detach the faceplate of the existing light switch, unscrew the mounting screws of the current switch, and disconnect the wires.
  • Connect the New Switch: Attach the live (hot) wire to the live terminal of the new switch and connect the load wire to the load terminal. Ensure all connections are securely tightened.
  • Install the Faceplate: Mount the new switch onto the wall, affix the switch faceplate, and turn the power back on.

Conclusion

Understanding the distinction between neutral and non-neutral wires is crucial for ensuring the proper functioning of a smart home system.

MOES's non-neutral smart light switches offer a practical solution for homes without a neutral wire, making smart home upgrades more accessible.

By correctly installing these switches, you can enjoy the benefits and comfort of a smart home without the need to alter your existing electrical wiring.

Back to blog